Tuesday, April 28, 2026

A Job Offer Turned Deadly: The 1860 Iowa City Murder Case

 

Jerry Boyd and his wife were offered a good paying job in Iowa City

How does that old saying go? If it’s too good to be true, it probably is.

Jerry Boyd learned that lesson the hard way back in 1860. Boyd, a free man of color, and his wife, Mary, lived in Galena, Illinois. From all accounts, Jerry was a hardworking man. Twenty years before that, he saved his money and purchased Mary from her previous owner, a man named Vandeventer in St. Louis.

 

Two men, George Goodwin (also known as Wilder) and Peter Boulton offered them good paying jobs if they would move to Iowa City.

 

A few days later, Jerry and Mary Boyd, a fourteen-year-old mulatto girl who lived with them, a younger white girl whom Mrs. Boyd was nursing, and Goodwin and Boulton were headed west in a covered wagon.


On the third day out of Galena, they made camp about sixteen miles outside of Iowa City. Something about Goodwin and Boulton triggered Boyd’s suspicions. He grabbed a revolver and loaded it while the two men watched.


Something about Goodwin and Boulton triggered Jerry's suspicions. so he grabbed his gun

The next morning, Goodwin and Boulton went off on their own to talk. When they got back, Goodwin walked up to Jerry, looked down at him, and whispered, “Jerry, I am afraid of you.” Then he pulled out a pistol and shot him in the chest, and again in the head, while his wife and the mulatto girl watched. That was on September 30, 1860.

 

After they killed Jerry Boyd, the men took the three women south to St. Louis, where they attempted to sell them into slavery. The deal for Mrs. Boyd and the fourteen-year-old mulatto girl who traveled with them was $1700. Before the transaction could be completed, Mary told the slave trader that the men kidnapped them and killed her husband. Luckily for her, he was an honest man. He delayed the transaction long enough to check with the authorities in Galena.

 

The Mayor of Galena sent Mr. Weigley and Mr. Hughlett to identify the women. Goodwin and Boulton were held in the jail at St. Charles pending the arrival of the men from Galena.

 

About the same time this was happening, Jerry Boyd’s body was discovered along the roadside, three miles west of Solon, near the residence of Shroeder De Vault. The body was severely decayed and well chewed by Mr. De Vault’s hogs. The skull was badly fractured, and other portions of the remains showed signs of a violent end.


Goodwin shot Jerry in the chest and head, killing him instantly

It turned out the Boyds weren’t the people kidnapped by Goodwin and Boulton. In August 1860, they kidnapped Mary Baker of Dubuque using the same ploy. They told her they had a good-paying job for her in Iowa City.

 

The men from Galena identified Mary Boyd and the two girls and took them back to Galena. They also took Mary Baker back to her home in Dubuque.

 

The authorities in Missouri tossed Boulton in the caboose in St. Charles. Goodwin was taken to Hannibal, Missouri, by train. He bided his time and escaped by jumping out the window of a train car moving at thirteen miles per hour. 

 

From the sound of it, both men escaped justice. By law, Negroes were property in 1860, not people, and as such, they had no standing in the legal system.

 

Abraham Lincoln would soon change that.

 

Stuff like this is what I always end up chasing—the little lines in old newspapers and magazines, the parts most books skip over.

I pulled a bunch of those stories together into Iowa Crime Time if you want more of it.

And if you just like reading this kind of thing, Buy me a Big Gulp / Support Retro Iowa

No comments:

Post a Comment